Monday, March 8, 2010

Teaching Journal (5): Demystify Writing

Week 8: Ever since I watched Peter Elbow On Writing (Patricia H. Mangan, 1995, MEF) with my writing group last year, I’ve been wanting to screen the video in a class. I got my chance this week. It’s a fantastic video that demystifies the writing process and begins with Elbow’s “confession” about how he flunked out of grad school the first time around because he couldn’t write... only to return and complete his PhD in English.


After screening the video, I listed Elbow’s four types of audience responses on a Powerpoint slide: 1) free-writing (no audience, private writing, lowest risk); 2) no response (someone reads your writing but provides absolutely no response); 3) response but no evaluation (someone reads your writing then echoes back what s/he thinks the piece is about: “I think you’re saying that...”); and 4) response with evaluation (someone, usually a teacher or an authority figure, reads your writing then evaluates it, highest risk).


The students were to submit their final essay proposal in two weeks so I asked them to bring their paper ideas to class this week to workshop it with peers, using Elbow’s audience response framework. I divided them into groups of similar topic areas (e.g. reproductive technologies, biomedicine, media & representation, surveillance technologies, video games) then asked them to do each activity in sequence. It wasn’t entirely successful. Students found it difficult to not respond and to respond without providing critiques or suggestions. Regardless, they seemed to enjoy the exercise for the most part and very much enjoyed the video. At least one student found the exercise uncomfortable, calling it “group therapy-like”, but I also explains that #3 and #4 audience responses is actually integrated into the peer review process in academic publishing... and so it is part of the “professional” process of writing.


A student came to see me during my office hour after class to discuss her paper and we chatted about writing in general. She really appreciated the exercise and the video, as English is her second language, and she felt that the undergraduate curriculum provides very little support and guidance for students when it comes to writing. I echo her concerns, particularly in the humanities and social sciences. Students are expected to have learned how to formulate arguments and to write an argumentative essay in high school but this skill is never fully developed in secondary education so that when students arrive at post-secondary institutions, they are expected to perform at a level that is unrealistic for them. They simply haven’t been taught... properly.


Beyond the academic, writing is a significant aspect of civic engagement: petitions, letters to government representatives, to newspapers and to corporations, and publishing on online forums, such as Facebook and other social networking sites are growing areas in which individuals contribute to thought development, governance and politics. Writing is also an important aspect of critical thinking, not only to express thought but also to develop and engage critical thought... which we all know is in dire need right now in public discourse. A simple exercise as this can help immensely to demystify the writing process and to make it more accessible and manageable for students.

Saturday, February 27, 2010

Teaching Journal (4): Violence in the Classroom

Week 6: I encountered my first significant difficulty on the Biometrics, Criminality and Surveillance week. All the readings centered on the use of biometric and surveillance technology at the border in the “war on terror”. The readings were quite dense. One document the historical emergence of biometric technology (Foucauldian genealogy), two were semiotic (semi-psychoanalytic) analysis of images and text. Neither of the student presentations addressed the close reading and dwelled on a notion (not found in the readings) that border technologies are not “effective”.


Thus far, the student presentations had been well done and I began to rely on them to jump start the class discussions. The presenters for this week had grossly misread the readings and we spiralled into a strange conversation. The students were very set on “catching the terrorist” and deeply invested in the constructed notion of security. I let the students speak pop-corn style and eventually I stopped them and asked “What is a terrorist?”. In my attempt to deconstruct the binary rhetoric of security vs. threat, I asked just how much of their freedoms and rights they are willing to give up to the state in the name of security, which is itself manufactured.


One white male student claimed that he has been stopped and his files examined at the airport during travels and felt that he is willing to give up a small amount of freedom because he knows he’ll be let go at the end. I felt the violence of that statement resonate in the classroom. What do I do as an instructor in such situations? Due to my general aversion to conflict, my immediate reaction was to open it up to the class. Luckily one student critically intervened. I asked the class who has been stopped at the border or their names caught on some kind of watch-list. About five raised their hands, including the white male student. The other four were either people of colour or racially white but (as we had established in previous classes) had racialized names. I was stuck again. I didn’t want to point this out, thereby tokenizing or highlighting their marginality without their consent. But I wasn’t sure whether my point came across.


I realized that, when it comes to border security, many university students have a difficult time with critical engagement. I also realized that I don’t have the skills to deal with comments that reinforce dominant ideology and perpetuate violence in the classroom. I think that as a critical scholar committed to anti-discrimination and anti-oppression, I lack the skills and know-how to address these issues in class discussions. I’ve been drawing on my experiences from my days of queer youth organizing and AIDS education but I need more specific strategies for the classroom. The events of this class deeply affected me. I felt that I had failed some students (including the one who spoke out at the problematic comment) and failed my own politics. My friend assured me that I did the best that I could. Talking with her, I realized that I need anti-discrimination and anti-oppression training. I remember from my years in Toronto that there are community advocacy organizations who conduct such workshops in community groups and other companies/organizations. They have a wealth of knowledge and know-how in dealing with oppression in social/classroom situations . I need help to actualize and strategize my theoretical training.

Friday, February 26, 2010

editing other people's writing

I have been editing a lot of other people’s writing lately: my students’ first assignment and a close friend’s article drafts. Not only is it a delicious break from my own writing, especially if it’s a beautiful piece of work as was my friend’s fabulous analysis of zombie films, but it’s a great opportunity to hone my editing skills.

My students submitted the first (of three) concept papers early this month. I gave them the option to submit one of the three papers as a revised edit of a previous paper. This meant that I had to grade the papers differently. I ignored grammatical errors, unless they repeated consistently, and instead focused on structure and logical flow of argument. I didn’t “correct errors” but alerted the students to their weaknesses and strengths and sections where they can write with greater clarity. It took a bit longer to grade these papers but I knew the work I put in now will come back in the form of improved papers the next time around. At least I hope!

I used similar editing strategies when I read my friend’s article. I saw several incarnations of this piece, from point form notes to the final draft and at each point my friend asked me to read the piece in a certain way. For example, she asked that I comment on overall structure of argument in the point form notes. Later stages of the draft required more meticulous reading, such as sentence structures. As an editor, you have to be attuned to the needs of the writer at a given stage of their writing. There’s no point in correcting grammatical errors at the point form stage! What a waste of your time and their time. You can be spending that time to really pay attention to overall structure and “map” of argument.

While I edited my friend’s drafts, I also wrote the first working (rough) draft of one of my dissertation chapters. Being in the editing mind-space and writing at the same time proved to be extremely useful for me. I edited my own writing as I wrote, but in a different way than I did before (see Wednesday, August 27, 2008 post). I wasn’t hyper-editing to the point of censoring myself, but I would write and then look at what I’ve written to check for sentence structure (redundant? awkward? confusing?) and the sentence’s contirbution/role in the overall paragraph/section (necessary? flows logically? should be somewhere else?). I would “flag” sections I am uncertain about with a grey highlight (as I would when I’m editing someone else’s writing) and make comments to myself in Italics (“need better transition”, “put somewhere else?”).

I have a looming deadline for a working draft of my full dissertation (August!) and it’s easy for me to refuse doing anything else, much less work on other people’s writing. But it’s all part of improving and fine-tuning my writing skills at all stages of writing, which includes editing. There’s the added bonus of reading something other than my own writing (that I stare at day in and day out) and subject matter (look! zombies!!).

Monday, February 1, 2010

Teaching Journal (3): Close reading exercise

Week 5: I tried something completely new today, what I decided to call "close reading exercise." It turned out that a student had dropped the course and one of the readings for this week did not have an assigned student presenter. I had initially decided to lecture on it myself but then I came up with a different plan.

The students had just submitted their first concept paper, which is basically a key-term paper and so relies on close reading of text and comprehension. Yet I've come to realize, as a former undergraduate myself, that students are not really taught how to read these texts that often use sophisticated stylistic devices, such as irony and imagery. I keep wondering just how much students fully understand the readings. Or are they assuming the meaning of what they read? Or are they projecting what they want to read?

I divided the article, "Straw men and their followers" by Evelynn Hammonds, into four sections and divided the class into four groups. Each group was responsible for reading one section, summarize it, point out the arguments, identify stylistic devices and style of reasoning. I wanted to give them about 10 mins for the exercise but the discussions were quite lively and it was obvious to me that they were really engaging with one another and with the text so I let it go on for 20 mins.

At the very least from the immediate verbal feedback, students pointed out that there were slight discrepancies in how they read the text but also how each person ended up contradicting her/himself in trying to encapsulate Hammonds' argument. They pointed out stylistic devices, such as tone, sarcasm, irony, use of air quotes and rhetorical questions and the ways in which these devices help to support her argument.

Some of the drawbacks of this exercise were that, because students were given sections of an article, they weren't aware of the bigger picture in the argument. There were some misunderstandings and confusion as a result. But I pointed out that this confusion points to the importance of argumentative flow and completeness, as well as writings that get taken out of context, which not only happens in academia but also journalism and everyday interactions.

I personally found the exercise helpful. It gave me a chance to see how they read. And I think it did the same for them... at least, that's what I hope. I ended the exercise by explaining my rationale. We are so well trained to critique, critique, critique that we forget to really pay attention to what someone writes and honour their position as well as the work they have put into their work. I asked whether anyone has had an experience where they were arguing with someone but it turned out they were arguing about completely different things or were actually arguing for the same thing. This happens in academic writing as well. Misreading and misunderstanding are fairly common. Close-reading and writing concept papers are part of my effort to develop skills in meaningful critique, which I believe starts with close-reading and comprehension.

Friday, January 29, 2010

Teaching Journal (2): Politics of humour

Week 4: The topic of this week was Classifying Difference, specifically race and sex/gender. I hadn't established ground rules or a learning contract with the students yet so I decided that this week would be a good time to do this, partially as a way to mitigate potentially problematic comments. I explained the usual points, such as respect (as pointed out by one of the students) and "I" statements. But I knew I wanted to really qualify the meaning of "respect."

One of the things I emphasized was that we need to pay careful attention to humour, that what we find funny is highly political. I asked the students, "What do we find funny?" After a brief moment of silence, one student answered, "A dog on a skateboard." Giggles from class. I asked, "Why is that funny?" Quiet. The same student mumbled something about a dog doesn't go on a skateboard normally. More giggles.

I took it up at this point and pointed out how a lot of humour is based on transgressing or pushing against boundaries of normality. So the image of a dog on a skateboard is funny because it blurs the boundary between human and dog. Dogs are supposed to be a certain way and not a certain way, i.e. human-like. Similarly, there are many different types of boundaries that can be crossed that could culturally register as humorous.

I decided on addressing politics of humour on a whim but I realized it's a great way to bridge discrimination at a conceptual level and at a practical level by engaging in how it manifests itself in everyday life.

Sometimes students are quite brilliant at coming up with the right examples, often without realizing it. It was a close one because I sure didn't have an example of something humorous! Dog on skateboard. I'm tucking that one away for future use.

Friday, January 22, 2010

Teaching Journal

I am teaching my second course this semester: a third-year seminar entitled "New Information Technology & Society", which I'm teaching as a science & technology studies (STS) course. My supervisor has advised me to keep a journal during teaching, as a way to reflect on my pedagogy and as a document to refer to when I put together a job application. I decided that this blog will serve as part of my journal-keeping.

Round two of teaching is infinitely easier. I think it's a combination of having some experience now and the class being mostly fourth- and fifth-years. I don't have to return to as many fundamental concepts, which makes such a topical seminar actually workable. I can say, "Hey, remember the concepts of racialization and borders? See how they play out in the context of the permanent resident card." The discussions are livelier, full of real-life examples as well as theoretical conversations.

I still have immense nausea before every class. I have trouble sleeping the night before, going over the possible class discussions in my head over and over. It also doesn't help that it's yet another new class that I'm teaching. I long for the day when I get to teach a course for the second or third time so that I can relax a bit and tweak things here and there. Assignments are also a cause for confusion as this course is turning out to be a workshop for these assignments. I'm hoping they will work but who knows for sure?

One thing I'm trying for this course is to use use more concrete examples, partly because the course material lends itself to real-life examples, partly because they facilitate learning, partly because it makes my life easier as an instructor.

Week 1: I divided the students into four groups of five and gave them a piece of technology to analyze for social, political, cultural, economic and historical contexts: washing machine, gun, phone and bicycle. I had somewhat randomly come up with those examples, but luckily they covered a lot of areas: feminism, criminalization of poverty, individualization and privacy, and urbanization and the politics of space.

Week 3: This is an activity idea I had gotten while helping my supervisor's plan for her community survey course. In the previous class, I asked the students to bring a newspaper to the next class. I had assigned Ian Hacking's "Making Up People" in the course readings for the week. After watching Chimamanda Adichie's talk, "The Danger of the Single Story", that is a brilliant discussion about the danger of stereotypes, the students worked in pairs to find an article in their newspapers that "makes up people." I provided them a set of guiding questions, such as who is being "made up"? which "expert" knowledges are invoked to give legitimacy to the claims about the people? what is the story being told? are there any missing stories? The students talked a lot about the newspaper coverage of the earthquake in Haiti. One student pointed out how the newsmedia seems to neglect the fact that there is a significant social division based on class, showing only the destroyed buildings (i.e. of the very poor) while the homes of the wealthy, which are still standing, go unnoticed. The single story being told is that Haitians are poor, have no infrastructure and chaotic. I was very impressed by their analysis.

Monday, August 10, 2009

Small pleasures: updating the CV

I needed to update my Curriculum Vitae (CV) to apply for a teaching position. I haven't looked at my CV since around this time last year. Updating your CV can be uplifting for your confidence... but it can also be depressing. My previous CV update was a bit of the latter. All I did was add one tutor marking position, which wasn't nothing but seemed like a very small accomplishment. But I had written my Comps in the previous year so all the work I had done to date was toward my degree. Sometimes, you just have to relax and put things into perspective.

This time, I added one sessional instructor position, a conference presentation and two popular press publications. Sweet! Ah, small pleasures (and big disappointments)...!